Even though they both are very dark and creepy, they are very different. The UK one is blue and black, the second one has more color. The guy on the first one is sort of cute, and the background is super creepy! But, I still love the second one more. The scissors and knifes and other stuff on top of the crib? Are you serious!?!? Also the crib looks amazing, and this cover is so much creepier than the first one.
Which is why US wins HAND DOWN! The Replacement is one of the best covers of 2010!